DNA Test Reviews - Landscape of Best DNA Test Kit 2025

‍

The "Landscape of DNA Test 2025" survey was conducted between January 27 and February 3, 2025, via Genomelink, with no audience filters. Participants were asked which DNA test they used—AncestryDNA, 23andMe, or MyHeritage—and why. You can find a copy of the original survey here. This analysis presents a fact-based summary of the results, highlighting satisfaction scores, recommendation rates, and key insights for different testing purposes.

‍

2025 Highlights

Purpose	Best Test	Reasoning
Genealogical Research	AncestryDNA	Largest user base, extensive family tree tools, historical records integration.
Exploring Ethnicity & Origins	AncestryDNA	Slightly higher recommendation rate than 23andMe, strong ethnicity estimate database.
Connecting with Relatives	AncestryDNA	More extensive relative-matching pool due to its larger database.
Health Insights & Traits	23andMe	FDA-authorized health reports, disease risk assessments, and carrier status insights.

‍

Number of Respondents per Test

A total of 1,123 participants responded to the survey, with the distribution as follows:

Test	Number of Respondents
AncestryDNA	829
23andMe	387
MyHeritage	345

‍

Satisfaction Scores (Overall & By Purpose)

Overall Satisfaction (All Purposes)

Satisfaction was measured as the percentage of users rating their test 9 or 10 on a scale of 1–10.

Test	Satisfaction Score
AncestryDNA	62%
23andMe	62%
MyHeritage	62%

(All three tests received an equal satisfaction rating when considering all purposes.)

Satisfaction by Purpose

Purpose	AncestryDNA	23andMe	MyHeritage
Genealogical Research	64%	61%	46%
Exploring Ethnicity & Origins	61%	59%	59%
Connecting with DNA Relatives	59%	57%	58%
Health Insights & Traits	62%	61%	61%

‍

Which Test Would You Recommend? (Overall & By Purpose)

Overall Recommendation

Percentage of users who recommended each test:

Test	% Who Recommend
AncestryDNA	68.2%
23andMe	53.5%
MyHeritage	31.3%

‍

Recommendation by Primary Purpose

Purpose	AncestryDNA	23andMe	MyHeritage
Genealogical Research	44.8%	29.2%	15.7%
Health Insights & Traits	13.8%	31.5%	7.2%
Exploring Ethnicity & Origins	41.7%	32%	22.9%
Connecting with Relatives	24%	17.6%	11%

‍

Head-to-Head Comparisons

AncestryDNA vs. 23andMe (233 respondents)

Category	AncestryDNA	23andMe	MyHeritage
Overall Recommendation	45.9%	42.5%	3.9%
Genealogical Research	30%	30%	3.9%
Health & Traits	12.4%	25.8%	1.7%
Ethnicity & Origins	29.2%	27%	2.6%
Connecting Relatives	18%	15.9%	2.1%

‍

AncestryDNA vs. MyHeritage (212 respondents)

Category	AncestryDNA	MyHeritage	23andMe
Overall Recommendation	55.7%	16.5%	17.9%
Genealogical Research	31.8%	11.2%	10.7%
Health & Traits	9.4%	5.6%	7.3%
Ethnicity & Origins	30.9%	9.9%	11.6%
Connecting Relatives	22.3%	8.2%	7.3%

‍

Why Users Recommend Each Test

AncestryDNA

Large Database & DNA Matches: 45% of respondents emphasized its extensive user base, providing more DNA relatives and family connections.
Ease of Use & Interface: 35% found AncestryDNA simple to navigate with clear results.
Detailed Ethnicity & Accurate Results: 25% appreciated the depth of ancestry breakdowns.
Genealogical Integration & Family Tree Tools: 23% highlighted the seamless connection to historical records.

23andMe

Health & Medical Insights: 22% valued disease risk and carrier status insights.
Depth of Information & Accuracy: 28% praised its robust data and haplogroup information.
Ancestry & Genealogy Detail: 19% found its ethnicity breakdowns comprehensive.
Family Connections: 12% noted the ability to discover distant relatives.

MyHeritage

Accuracy & Detailed Ethnicity: 31% appreciated its precise ancestry estimates.
Ease of Use & Interface: 21% found the platform intuitive.
Large Database & Matches: 20% highlighted strong international matches.
Genealogy Tools & Integration: 14% cited useful features like family tree building.
Affordability: 13% praised its budget-friendly options.

‍

Final Analysis & Answers

Which Is the Best DNA Test Overall?

AncestryDNA leads overall with 68.2% of users recommending it, particularly excelling in genealogy and DNA matching.

Which Purpose Is Best Served by Each Test?

Purpose	Best Test	Reasoning
Genealogical Research	AncestryDNA	Largest user base, extensive family tree tools, historical records integration.
Exploring Ethnicity & Origins	AncestryDNA	Slightly higher recommendation rate than 23andMe, strong ethnicity estimate database.
Connecting with Relatives	AncestryDNA	More extensive relative-matching pool due to its larger database.
Health Insights & Traits	23andMe	FDA-authorized health reports, disease risk assessments, and carrier status insights.

‍

Conclusion

Based on the internal survey results, AncestryDNA is the best overall choice, particularly for genealogical research and relative matching. 23andMe stands out for health insights, making it the go-to for users interested in medical-related DNA analysis. MyHeritage appeals to budget-conscious users who seek affordable ancestry testing, especially with strong European match potential. The choice of DNA test ultimately depends on the individual’s goals—whether ancestry, health, or family discovery.

‍

DNA Test Reviews: Landscape of Best DNA Test Kit 2025